Exercise Overview: Kiteley asks the writer to create a story in which a man and a woman are binary opposites, then you extract 2/3 what you've written and add in as much as you've taken out. Here's what I got.
Original Text
It was hard to define exactly what brought Maisie and James together. When standing together, she came just up to his shoulders and could just barely get her twiggy arms around his thick neck. Despite his physical bulk overwhelming her petite frame, her voice carried across the plains while he preferred to live his life quietly and with purpose. Where she was a talker, he was a doer. She wrote stories in her mind about love and conquest and what exactly her crazy old cat woman neighbor did at night. When she told James the stories, he wasn’t reproachful but instead shrugged his shoulders and went back to work. Oftentimes it was said that she brought a lighthearted happiness in the relationship and he was the anchor, though this seemed hardly fair. If she was to be the sun, that would make him the moon, and that just never seemed comfortable.
Maisie loved the Spring but James flourished in the fall. When she decorated their apartment with lilies, he sneezed in the corner from the accumulating pollen. As he took her on hikes through the park to admire the changing of the leaves, and just perhaps get a nostalgic glimpse of youth playing a haphazard game of football, she wrapped heavy scarves around her neck to keep out the chill.
They kept separate workspaces for weekend projects. James enjoyed the refuge of his garage workshop. Though there were tools for woodworking and home projects, he also kept a secret stash of archival New York Times crossword puzzles and had a DVD collection of various documentaries that he knew his better half would find outright boring. Maisie’s personal space was up in their attic, which was really more of a crawl space. She loved the glimpses of sunlight that shone through the small windows and the assortment of benign spiders that crawled along the exposed brick of her space. Her hobby room was a graveyard of long-forgotten projects. A sewing machine with bits of quilt work still draped above it, a corkboard with various notes from her ill-fated novel aspirations, and recipes in search of the perfect ice cream littered the area. She didn’t mind that her room was where hobbies went to die, but she cautiously avoided this graveyard of ideas after dark.
When they sat down to eat, all bets were off. He introduced her to the joys of a steak that was still red in the middle while she surreptitiously changed out his American cheese for all things smelly. His sweet tooth frequently invaded her love of the savory but together they avoided all things potato, for no apparent reason.
Minus 2/3
It was hard to define exactly what brought Maisie and James together. When standing together, she came just up to his shoulders. Her voice carried across the plains while he preferred to live his life quietly. She told stories of love and conquest and what exactly her crazy old cat woman neighbor did at night.
Maisie loved the spring but James flourished in the fall.
They kept separate workspaces for weekend projects. James enjoyed the refuge of his garage workshop. He also kept a secret stash of archival New York Times crossword puzzles and had a DVD collection of various documentaries. Maisie’s personal space, up in their attic, was really more of a crawl space. She didn’t mind that her room was where hobbies went to die, but she cautiously avoided this graveyard of ideas after dark.
When they sat down to eat, all bets were off. Together they avoided all things potato, for no apparent reason.
Rewrite
It was hard to define what exactly brought Maisie and James together. When standing next to one another, she came just up to his shoulders. To combat any awkward movements in public situations, she frequently wore high heels and he developed a slight, and quite unintentional, stoop. Another equalizing factor was the sheer amount of noise Maisie produced. When she so desired, her voice could carry across the plains while he preferred to live his life quietly. In the silences that might fill a car ride or a wait in the doctor’s office, she told stories of love and conquest and what exactly her crazy old cat lady neighbor did at night. Though James never participated in such stories, he refrained always from giving her the quizzical looks that naturally came to him.
Maisie loved the spring, but James flourished in the fall. She rejoiced in tennis and patterned skirts, but ragweed and pollen always got the better of him. He hoped in secret to convert her to an autumn bloomer and considered their outings to football games small personal victories. To encourage her shift, he frequently made gifts of scarves and told her how attractive she looked while wearing her prized riding boots.
The couple kept separate workspaces for weekend projects. James enjoyed the refuge of his garage workshop. Under the guise of a crafter’s paradise, he kept a secret stash of archival New York Times crossword puzzles which he filled in meticulously using a pencil with no eraser. Maisie’s personal space, up in their attic, was really more of a crawl space. Though she kept bits and pieces of the ghosts of hobbies past, the main attraction was the proliferation of benign spiders that slowly made their way from one cobwebbed corner to another. Something about the accumulation of forgotten pastimes and dark spaces appealed to her, but she cautiously avoided the room after sunset.
When they sat down to eat, all bets were off. Though he preferred sweet and she craved savory, they had one enemy in all things potato. At one recent dinner party, Maisie had gotten herself quite drunk in using red wine to slosh down the aftertaste of the host’s gnocchi. James had to support her quite generously through their entire underground experience home, but he didn’t mind. Having endured years of latkes from his Bubby, this was one experience he understood.
The exact exercise can be found on p. 73 of Kiteley's book, I encourage anybody to pick up the book for his or herself.